Julia Hartley-Brewer examines Keir Starmer’s chances of staying as prime minister. 

After Labour lost over 1500 councillors in local elections on Thursday, the floodgates have opened: over 50 MPs have demanded Keir Starmer resign. They want a leadership contest - with Angela Rayner, Andy Burnham and Wes Streeting all listed as potential candidates. 

To garner any remaining support, the PM made a speech this morning, wherein he vowed to nationalise British steel, bring the UK to the ‘heart of Europe’, and a youth experience scheme with the EU. 

He also took responsibility for the local election results. 

But it wasn’t enough to stem the calls for him to go. 

Catherine West MP, a relatively unknown backbencher who caused panic over the weekend by saying she would challenge Keir Starmer if nobody in the cabinet did by this morning, decided the speech wasn’t enough to stop her from asking MPs to support a timeline for Sir Keir to leave. 

She did row back on her leadership challenge threat though. 

With her guests, Julia reacts to the speech. She debates Lord Foulkes, Labour peer, on whether Keir Starmer is right for the job. She asks Richard Tice MP about a £5m donation he didn’t declare, and a Reform councillor saying ‘Nigerians should be melted down to fill in potholes’. 

Then, Karl Turner diagnoses what’s wrong with the Labour party, and backs Angela Rayner as the next Labour leader. 

Julia Hartley-Brewer broadcasts on Talk from Monday to Thursday, 10AM to 1PM.

Available on YouTube and streaming platforms, along with DAB+ radio and your smart speaker.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Folgen-ID: 1000767193688

GUID: 6a01bedf5c981a3573d69461

Erscheinungs­datum: 11.5.2026, 15:06:15